• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
ClassThink

ClassThink

School Technology Guides

  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • HOME
  • LATEST
  • Featured
  • School App Search
    • Search
    • Dashboard
    • Directory Login
  • TEACHER GUIDES
    • Microsoft Teams
      • Microsoft Teams Teacher’s Hub
    • Microsoft OneDrive
    • Microsoft Stream
    • Microsoft Office
    • Microsoft Edge
    • Microsoft OneNote
    • Microsoft Office
    • Microsoft Outlook
    • Microsoft Windows
    • Microsoft SDS
    • Google Classroom
    • Google Meet
    • Zoom
  • REVIEWS
  • NEWSLETTER
  • ABOUT
    • Contact Us
    • About ClassThink
    • Support ClassThink
    • Write for ClassThink
    • Advertising and Sponsorship
You are here: Home / iPad / The future of BYOD in schools

The future of BYOD in schools

9 April 2014 by Karl Rivers 2 Comments

In the rush to get tablets into the hands of our students are we forgetting the principals of good planning that we’ve built up over the last 20 years?

I’m currently involved in the early stages of planning a 1:1 iPad roll out for one of the schools my team support. The project is really exciting to be involved with, but trying to make long-term plans in a market which is still immature and fluctuating is incredibly difficult.

The decisions we make will not only affect every teacher and student but also the school’s budget and the finances of every single family involved in the scheme.

Below are some of my initial thoughts on the project. As we progress I will document the different stages and choices we made during development.

Does every student really need an iPad?

For me, this an easy question to answer. While I would agree that there isn’t enough solid research to conclude that each student having a personal device in the classroom equates to improved student attainment, the general consensus is that personal mobile devices do have a positive influence on learning. Whether this is by improving student – teacher engagement, increasing engagement, or simply making technology more accessible most schools that have a BYOD or 1:1 strategy find that it has had a positive influence in the classroom. 

But, contrary to what you may expect, the affect on teaching and learning will not be the primary reason to promote BYOD in schools. In fact maintaining the status quo may be impossible. The question isn’t whether students need mobile technology, it’s how urgent is the demand.

In the very near future every student, from our youngest to our oldest, will have a personal mobile device. The student without a tablet or phone will be the exception not the rule, and schools will be forced to accept BYOD as a normal part of school life. The only area of contention is timescale, and whether this is something we need to push through or can wait for it to develop organically.

1:1 is not a way to shift costs from the school

Part of our 1:1 discussion was how to make the case to parents that having them enter into a lease agreement for their child was necessary. I’m convinced that as a school we can demonstrate a definite benefit to teaching and learning, but there are organisation that are using potential financial saving to look at BYOD leasing schemes.

The idea that in a state system we should require parents to purchase an expensive item in order to benefit their child’s education in not sustainable in the long term. It raises issues such as segregation in an otherwise free education system. We’re essentially saying to parents, “unless you buy this £400 device you child’s education will be negatively affected.”

One supplier contacted me using this sentence in their promotional material:

“BYOD programs generally shift costs to the user, therefore, cutting school costs. 50 percent of schools with BYOD models are requiring teachers to cover all costs, no expense back or stipend.”

To say I was outraged was an understatement. The clear indication is that schools should use BYOD as an excuse to cut ICT spending by dumping costs on to teachers and parents. Costs savings are a genuine reason to promote BYOD, but not the primary reason and certainly not at the expense of teachers.

In the coming years, as tablets and other mobile devices become ubiquitous the argument for school leasing schemes, particularly iPads will weaken. When a parent can walk the local supermarket and pick up a good tablet for £100, the £380 offering of an iPad from the school looks much less attractive.

Final Thought

Tablets will become essential tools in all aspects of our lives. They are the every man’s way of accessing a world of information, but we need more Ford Fiesta and less Rolls Royce in our schools to continue this spread of mobile technology. The future of BYOD and 1:1 is in low cost devices that reflect consumer choice and, more importantly, the choices of students.

School leadership presently finds itself in an awkward position. We have to be seen to be pushing the boundaries of technology while at the same time being mindful that we have a responsibility to plan for the next three, four, or five years of a student’s education.

Schools should concentrate less on providing hardware and more on services which encourage students to purchase devices without putting pressure on parents. Coming from an educational technologist this may sound contradictory, but instead of sprinting headlong into expensive leasing schemes and short term platform decisions we should tread carefully. Allow BYOD to develop organically and let our students lead.

Very few people are prepared to say, “let’s wait a few years,” but maybe this is just what we should be doing.

You might also like...

Filed Under: BYOD, Featured, iPad

This page contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on the links to these products. For an explanation of our Affiliate Policy, please visit this page.

About Karl Rivers

Karl Rivers is a Director of IT who has worked in education for more than twenty years. He won the Naace Impact Award for Supporting School Services.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jamie Thompson says

    04/24/2014 at 11:56 am

    I agree that school’s need to be putting in place services that are as platform-agnostic as possible. Microsoft RemoteApps, Exchange and Google Apps spring to mind. There’s an inevitability about students bringing in their own Android, iOS, and MacOS devices to a school full of Windows machines: enabling their use as much as possible ought to take priority over prescribing one particular device.

    Log in to Reply
    • Karl Rivers says

      04/25/2014 at 10:57 am

      Hi!

      Completely agree. I can’t help but feel that despite Microsoft’s sluggish attempt to transition into a services company that the core of their business still relies on Windows.

      Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

You might also like...

Popular School Apps

  • Bromcom Computers Plc

    Bromcom Computers Plc

    MIS/SIS System

  • CleverTouch

    CleverTouch

    Classroom Screens & Projectors

  • Capita SIMS

    Capita SIMS

    MIS/SIS System +3 Parent Communications, Parent Portal, Parents Evenings,

  • Wakelet

    Wakelet

    Learning Platform +1 Social Bookmarking,

  • BKSK

    BKSK

    Assessments +1 Educational Games & Quizzes,

Latest Edtech News

Virtual breakout rooms for Microsoft Teams – everything you need to know

Download the free OneNote for Team Collaboration eBook

New Surface Laptop Go Announced

Featured

Best Chromebooks for students in 2021

Create beautiful infographics for your classroom

Record online lessons with Camtasia

Naace Impact Awards Winner

Footer

Recent

  • Best Chromebooks for students in 2021
  • Create beautiful infographics for your classroom
  • Virtual breakout rooms for Microsoft Teams – everything you need to know
  • Record online lessons with Camtasia
  • Download the free OneNote for Team Collaboration eBook
  • New Surface Laptop Go Announced
  • Managing Windows 10 in schools with Intune and Autopilot
  • How to stop students unmuting themselves in Microsoft Teams
  • How to spotlight students & demonstrations in Microsoft Teams meetings
  • How to record a PowerPoint presentation as a video
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Recent Forum Topics

  • JvFHf5vfJ HyVSv2mpZ
  • Use VPN Security
  • How less is more with application development
  • How Much Does it Cost to Make an App like Uber
  • Microsoft Team class not appearing for teacher but is correct in Teams admin
  • FCM Test Notification!!! message in Microsoft Teams
  • FAQ: Can students begin a meeting in a private channel in Microsoft Teams
  • Microsoft Lists for Education
  • Benefits of hiring a ghostwriter
  • Things You Need To Make An Android App

Most Popular Posts

  • How to turn off chat for students in Microsoft Teams
  • How to stop students muting and kicking others in Microsoft Teams video meetings
  • How to delete a video from Microsoft Teams
  • How to record and share a lesson in Microsoft Teams
  • How to enable Large Gallery view and Together Mode in Microsoft Teams
  • How to mute students in Microsoft Teams
  • Virtual breakout rooms for Microsoft Teams - everything you need to know
  • How to record a PowerPoint presentation as a video
  • Set students to attendee by default in Microsoft Teams meetings
  • How to set and mark an assignment in Microsoft Teams
  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2021 · ClassThink.com · Affiliate Disclaimer · Privacy Policy · Here's the secret · Log in